Grovel

Graphic novel news and reviews

Ghost in the Shell 1

Ghost in the Shell 1
Buy from Amazon.com
Buy from Amazon.co.uk

Written by: Masamune Shirow
Art by: Masamune Shirow
Publisher: Dark Horse (US), Titan Books (UK)
First published: 1991
Originally published as: Ghost in the Shell 1-8

Story:
Story rating
Art:
Art rating
Overall:
Overall rating



Much like manga classic Akira, Ghost in the Shell is a Japanese comic title that many westerners will recognise, largely due to the phenomenal success of animated the movie it inspired.

Ghost in the ShellSet twenty-five years into the future, Shirow’s vision isn’t desperately different to modern life, but the rapid pace of technology has converged robotics, medicine and networking. Receive a wound that doesn’t affect your brain or spine, and you’re more likely to end up with a new robotic body-part than find the injured organ patched-up or healed. Naturally, this throws up a flood of Blade Runner-type questions about where the line between human and robot can be drawn, especially with regards to Major Motoko Kusanagi, the cybernetic heroine of the piece.

The plot starts off comparatively simply, revolving around her group of Japanese anti-terrorist special agents code-named Section 9, working for the government on a number of covert missions to ensure the safety of its people. However, things start getting complicated as they begin to hunt down a particularly tricksy terrorist known only as the Puppeteer.

Shirow is expert at serial story-telling. Each chapter is a self-contained story, brimming with fast-paced action. But he also finds space for an undertow of political intrigue and plenty of character development, with all the people in his stories working to different agendas. His speculative future is fully populated with coherent technology, complete with scientific annotations should you want them, creating a believable future peopled by credible characters.

Ghost in the ShellWhere we feel he falls down is in his depiction of women. Although Kusanagi is a strong and motivated woman, Shirow has a tendency to pander to a drooling male audience and use titillating flashes of female flesh for very little effect. While the men in the series come in all shapes, sizes and levels of attractiveness, his women are all stereotypical fantasy figures. We only mention it to provide fair warning to those who find this sort of thing offensive or embarrassing, but there’s a scene or two in this volume that even broad-minded readers will concede serve little purpose beyond the pornographic.

If you can cope with the sexism though, it’s a blip in an otherwise momentous piece of futurism. Any sci-fi aficionado, even those who haven’t touched manga before, should consider making the leap with this volume, which is a deserved (if self-indulgent) classic. And if you’ve come from the film without having touched the book we urge you to give it a go, if only to add more depth to the story and characters you’re already familiar with.

Other titles in the Ghost in the Shell series:

By Andy • Nov 10th, 2006

Tags: First published/1991Rating/Story/4 starsRating/Overall/4 starsRating/Art/4 starsPublisher/Dark HorseSeries/Ghost in the ShellGenre/MangaReviewGenre/Science fictionArtist/Shirow, MasamuneWriter/Shirow, MasamunePublisher/Titan Books

2 Responses »

  1. [...] If you liked the first Ghost in the Shell book then this is not going to disappoint. It’s rammed with scantily clad clone babes connected to a complex network that exists both virtually and in the physical world - a rollercoaster ride of techno-babble and exposed female crotches. [...]

  2. [...] read our existing Ghost in the Shell reviews you’ll be well aware that we thought the first volume was a tour de force sci-fi techno-thriller, but the second was too abstract and stuck in [...]

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.